Jimmy John’s is a sandwich food chain that specializes in sub and club sandwiches. Jimmy John’s has 17 subs on their original and favorite menu and signature sides to go with them. They also have frequent limited-time options.
The food items on this list are all from the permanent Jimmy John’s menu as of 2023. At the end of this list, you can find a review of some of the ongoing limited-time items.
If you are wondering what the best pick is, or what people like to get, this list is for you. In this list, you will find a review of the subs served at Jimmy John’s from a firsthand experience.
Original Menu
The original menu has six numbered subs and the J.J.B.L.T.
According to Jimmy John’s, the subs in this menu are “Single protein and provolone served on 8″ or 16” French, sliced wheat or Unwich, plus the Veggie!”
#1 The Pepe ★★★☆☆
Basic ham and cheese sandwich. A tried and true combination of classic tastes. Also, according to Jenison Jimmy John’s employee, Braylon Williams, “THE most ordered original,”.
#2 Big John ★★☆☆☆
A roast beef sandwich with the classic additions. If you are a fan of simplicity and roast beef, this is the sandwich for you.
#3 Totally Tuna ★★★☆☆
A sub filled with tuna salad complimented by cucumbers and tomatoes. It is a flavorful option for someone who is looking for a sub without meat.
#4 Turkey Tom ★★★☆☆
A good-tasting turkey sandwich. Classic combination of turkey, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
#5 Vito ★★★★★
A sub with distinguishable salami, capocollo, and provolone. It is an interesting sub topped with oil & vinegar, oregano-basil, and the classic additions.
#6 The Veggie ★★★★☆
With provolone and avocado spread, this green-flavored sub will leave a lasting taste. With cucumbers, tomatoes, and lettuce filling this sub, it is a very well-rounded choice.
J.J.B.L.T ★★★☆☆
Imagine a classic BLT but as a sandwich. The classic bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo combination makes this sub a good option for most.
I haven’t tried some of the subs from this menu but, out of all that I have tried, Vito and The Veggie is my favorite. Vito has an interesting combination of meat. Every time I have it it always tastes new and fresh. The Veggie is a very green-tasting sandwich. The fresh veggies and avocado spread come together to make a very good original sub.
Favorites Menu
The favorite menu has eleven numbered subs.
The subs on the favorites menu are double protein and provolone. They are also served on the same types of bread as the original menu.
#7 Spicy East Coast Italian ★★★★☆
“One of the most underrated subs”, according to Jimmy John’s employee, Braylon Willaims. This packed sub is a must for people who like their food spicy and filling.
#8 Billy Club ★★★☆☆
A club with roast beef, ham, and provolone, topped with the tangy taste of Dijon. It is a must-try for people who like roast beef with some tangy flavor.
#9 Italian Night Club ★★★★★
With salami, ham, capocollo, and provolone, this makes a very well-matched club. The original additions, oil & vinegar, and oregano-basil to top it all off make it one of the best clubs on this list.
#10 Hunter’s Club ★★☆☆☆
A club packed with roast beef and some provolone. The Hunter’s Club does not have much else to offer other than roast beef. If you enjoy roast beef with classic tastes, this is another option for you.
#11 Country Club ★★★★☆
An amazing combination of turkey, ham, and provolone. This combination makes this flavourful club a great tasting option.
#12 Beach Club ★★★★★
Another very green-tasting club. The turkey, provolone, and avocado make this club a filling and amazing option.
#13 Jimmy Cubano ★★★★☆
Bacon, ham, and provolone with tangy tastes on the side. This club has a good combination of meat with pickles, mayo, and Dijon to add extra flavor.
#14 Bootlegger Club ★★★☆☆
A roast beef and turkey sandwich. The meats blend together well and with the mayo, makes for a well-rounded meal.
#15 Club Tuna ★★★☆☆
A club packed with double layers of tuna salad and provolone in the middle. The cucumbers bring this sandwich together to make a very tasty option.
#16 Club Lulu ★★★★★
A very good turkey club sandwich. Braylon Williams says, that “…the turkey compliments the bacon very well. Also one of the most commonly ordered,”.
#17 Ultimate Porker ★★★★☆
A ham and bacon club. It has all the basic additions and good flavors to go with.
This menu has a lot more protein combinations and because of that, the subs on this menu are more expensive. Even though they are more expensive, many of the combinations on this menu are very good. Out of all the subs, the #9 is usually my go-to pick from that list. It is filling and the toppings are perfect. I usually take the onions off and add Kickin Ranch if I am eating in. I also like this sub because it lasts a pretty long time refrigerated. Another one of my recent favorites is the #12. It has a green taste in every bite, and when put on wheat with a couple of choice toppings, it gets even better.
Sides
Besides subs, Jimmy John’s offers a bunch of options for sides. They have their signature Jimmy Chips that come in five popular flavors. They also have some dessert options to pair with your meal. Also, new limited-time sides are often added to the menu, so always watch out for something new to try out.
Starting out with their five signature chips. These crispy Jimmy Chips are a classic choice for any sandwich order.
BBQ ★★★★★
Classic and crispy barbeque-flavored chips. You can not go wrong with this bag.
Jalapeño ★★★☆☆
The jalapeño chips are a little spicy and have decent flavor. The jalapeño will match most sandwiches.
Salt & Vinegar ★★★★☆
It has a very good and strong salt and vinegar taste. You can rarely go wrong with this bag.
Regular ★★★★☆
Classic, crispy, potato chip flavor. This bag is a good pair with any sub on their menu.
Thinny ★★☆☆☆
This bag still has the crispy potato chip flavor but with lighter ingredients and taste. This bad will pair with almost anything.
Desserts
Another option to put on the side is these desserts. Whether you prefer a soft cookie or a fudge-filled brownie, Jimmy John’s has something for your sweet tooth.
Chocolate Chip Cookie ★★★★☆
A classic, soft, chocolate chip cookie. This classic cookie is a popular choice for many.
Oatmeal Rasin Cookie ★★★★★
Soft oatmeal cookie with added raisins. You can not go wrong with this cookie if you are looking for a desert on the side.
Fudge Chocolate Brownie ★★☆☆☆
A chocolatey brownie for anyone with a sweet tooth. This is a good-tasting brownie, but is expensive for the serving size you get.
Out of all the sides, my favorite is the BBQ chips. They are crispy and match with the most choice of subs. My close second is the Oatmeal Rasin Cookie. If I want a desert-style side, it is my go-to.
Wraps
Jimmy John’s does not have only sandwiches, they also have a small selection of wraps. The three wraps that are on their menu are good options for people who do not like their sandwich falling apart.
Chicken Ceasar Wrap ★★☆☆☆
It is a Caesar salad in a wrap. It has tasty chicken and parmesan, topped with Caesar dressing and crunchy croutons.
Jalapeño Ranch Chicken Wrap ★★★★★
Chicken and provolone combined with jalepeños and hot peppers make this wrap very tasty. The combination of spice and chicken makes this a good option for people who like spicy food.
Tuscan Italian Wrap ★★★★☆
Salami, capocollo, ham, and parmesan make this wrap very filling. The added toppings add so much more flavor and bring this wrap together.
Limited Time Subs
From time to time new limited-time options will appear on the menu. A well-known example in the past is the Red Velvet cookie. Right now, there is a new sub called the BBQ Ranch Chicken Crunch and a new side of Pickle flavored chips.
BBQ Ranch Chicken Crunch ★★★★★
This limited-time offer is very good. The quality chicken paired with the amazing-tasting sauces, and the crunch in every bite, make this sandwich delicious. The crispy tortilla chips make this sub a new, different, and very delicious option to their menu. I enjoy this sandwich a lot, especially in a wrap.
Pickle Chips ★★★★☆
On the level of Salt & Vinegar chips, this bag has a strong pickle flavor. Although, the pickle flavor might not be for most.
Also, a new addition to the side options at Jimmy John’s is salad bowls. Right now, there are two options for this type of premium side: Potato Salad and Pesto Bowtie Pasta. I have not tasted them, so I do not have a rating for them, but I have heard that they are alright.
I am not a very picky eater. I enjoy almost all the food on the Jimmy John’s menu. The sandwiches and sides are great and affordable. Also, the menu gets even better when you start customizing your own sandwich. They have so many options to make the perfect meal for you. Jimmy John’s is great, and whatever you decide to eat, I bet it will be “Freaky Fast” and “Freaky Fresh”.
